Is the Fury/Wilder rematch a clear “#1 Vs #2” match-up? The majority in the Boxing World say “No”

Tonight Tyson Fury attempts to defend the Heavyweight World Championship for the 6th time against America’s dynamite fisted Deontay Wilder.

As with many eagerly anticipated prize fights, in the days leading up to the bout, the intense hype around the promotion, often means the wider picture becomes a little blurred.

BT Sport, ESPN, the TBRB and The Ring, among other, have beaten the drum that Fury and Wilder are the clear top 2 in the division.

It seems Anthony Joshua is old news.

...until you check the bigger picture.

As of February 22nd, 2020, the morning of Fury/Wilder 2, the independent ratings among the following respected boxing websites are as follows:

Boxing News

#1 Joshua

#2 Fury

#3 Wilder

The Ring

#1 Fury

#2 Wilder

#3 Joshua

Boxing Monthly

#1 Joshua

#2 Fury 

#3 Wilder 

TBRB

#1 Wilder

#2 Fury

#3 Joshua

ESPN

#1 Wilder

#2 Joshua 

#3 Fury 

Joshua is currently rated #1 with two organisations. Wilder is also rated #1 with two. Fury is rated #1 with one. If 10 points are allocated for each #1 position, 9 points for #2, and 8 points for #3, Fury, Wilder and Joshua would all be tied at 45 points. 

There is no clear top 2.

Interestingly at the time of Joshua/Ruiz 2 in December 2019, Andy Ruiz Jr was rated at #1 by the TBRB. Joshua dominated Ruiz Jr, winning by as wide as 119/109 on one official card. Two weeks earlier Wilder had KO’d #6 rated Ortiz. Joshua moved up one place, to #3 with the TBRB, while Wilder jumped two places, from #3 to #1, following this victory over Ortiz (he had also previously defeated him in 2018).

Incidentally, for those who keep an eye on computer based ratings, BoxRec have the Heavyweights ranked as follows:

#1 Joshua 

#2 Wilder

#3 Usyk

#4 Fury

For the minority who believe the Lineal Championship is vacant, and desire a clear “#1 Vs #2” match-up to crown a new Champion, well, Fury/Wilder 2 is not the fight.

For the majority, tonight’s fight is defence No.6 of the Lineal Championship for Fury.

Adjustments.jpeg

Women's Monthly Rankings: February 2020

Screenshot (17).png
Screenshot (13).png
Screenshot (14).png
Screenshot (15).png
February 2020 Ratings - UpdatesMinimumweight: Yokasta Valle and Estuko Tada swap places, after Valle TKO victory over Carleans Rivas, and Tada’s recent draw with Ayaka Miyao.Bantamweight: Jackie Nava exits due to inactivity. Vanesa Taborda enters at…

February 2020 Ratings - Updates

Minimumweight: Yokasta Valle and Estuko Tada swap places, after Valle TKO victory over Carleans Rivas, and Tada’s recent draw with Ayaka Miyao.

Bantamweight: Jackie Nava exits due to inactivity. Vanesa Taborda enters at #5

Junior Lightweight: Terri Harper enters at #4 after widely
outpointing Eva Wahlstrom. Eva exits. Mi Choi drops to #5.

Lightweight: Amanda Serrano enters at #2. Rose Volante drops to #4. Macarena Ledesma exits due to inactivity.

Junior Welterweight: Mary McGee climbs to #4 after
stopping Deanha Hobbs, switching places with Christina Linardatou.

Middleweight: Maricela Cornejo exits due to inactivity at 160lbs. Espinosa rises to #4. Tayla Harris enters at #4.

Super Middleweight: The investigation
into Alejandra Jimenez’ positive PED test for her recent fight with Franchon Crews
Dezurn is still ongoing – no official verdict has yet been reached.

Pound-For-Pound: Our overall Pound-for-Pound top 10 is now worked out by allocating points to each panellist’s top 10, and totalling the figures – so, 10 points for each panellist’s #1, 9 points for #2...1 point for #10.

Ratings Panel

David Avila: 2019 Inductee IWBHF. Journalist at The Sweet Science. California, USA. @AvilaBoxing

Suzy Smith: Women’s boxing historian. United Kingdom. @SuzyQSmith360

Daniel Yanofsky: Women’s boxing journalist. New York, USA. @DanYanofsky

Ireneusz Fryszkowski: Women’s Boxing Journalist. Poland. @RingBlogpl

Julian Haramoure: Women’s Boxing Journalist. Argentina. @JulianFunky

Yuriko Miyata: Women’s Boxing Journalist. Japan. @Yuriyuri0803

GM Ross: Women’s Boxing Journalist. Canada. @CanadianBoxiana

Adam McMeeking: Editor of LinealBoxingChampion.com. United Kingdom. @LinealBoxChamp